Decisions

A collection of judgments of the Ontario Court of Justice, primarily released after April 1, 2004, is posted on CanLII. The CanLII website is not an exhaustive source of judgments of the Ontario Court of Justice. The official version of the reasons for judgment is the signed original or handwritten endorsement in the court file. In the event that there is a question about the content of a judgment, the original in the court file takes precedence.

Judgments are available in the language provided.

Copies of judgments of the Ontario Court of Justice can be obtained by contacting the respective court office where the matter was heard. A photocopy charge is payable. Judgments are also available on a number of subscription based services such as LexisNexis® QuicklawTM and WestlawNext® Canada.

Subscribe to the RSS Feed for Ontario Court of Justice Decisions

Ontario Court of Justice Recent Decisions

  • 2026-11-16 R. v. Maddaloni, 2026 ONCJ 689 (CanLII)
    Key Words: Procedure — Provincial Offences Act appeal — Deemed conviction — Appeal under Provincial Offences Act, s. 135, from conviction in absence — Early resolution meeting requested under Provincial Offences Act, s. 5.1 — Deeming provision under Provincial Offences Act, s. 9(1)(b) applied after non-attendance — Regulatory offence context emphasised — Appeal dismissed<br />Procedure — Waiver by inaction — Deeming provisions — Whether failure to attend early resolution meeting constituted valid waiver — Notice warned that non-attendance meant deemed not to dispute and conviction in absence — Voluntary conduct with knowledge of consequences assessed under R. v. Richard — Non-attendance treated as waiver of right to dispute charge — Appeal dismissed<br />Rights and freedoms — Procedural fairness — Disclosure — Whether absence of disclosure prevented an informed decision to attend early resolution meeting — Disclosure requested but not provided before scheduled meeting — Court found Appellant knew charge, purpose, options, and consequences — No specific prejudice identified beyond decision not to attend — Disclosure concerns not determinative on this appeal — Appeal dismissed<br />Procedure — Appellate remedies — Ends of justice — Whether intervention required under Provincial Offences Act, s. 138 — Power to affirm, reverse, vary, or direct new trial considered — Regulatory Highway Traffic Act context and available procedural options weighed — No basis established to set aside deemed conviction or order new trial — Appeal dismissed
  • 2026-11-12 R. v. Kelly, 2026 ONCJ 685 (CanLII)
    Key Words: Criminal and statutory offences — Impaired driving — Over 80 — Operating a conveyance with BAC exceeding legal limit — Breath samples central to prosecution — Charter application sought exclusion under s. 24(2) — Exclusion left Crown unable to prove BAC and related breach of order — Accused found not guilty<br />Constitution — Charter, s. 8 — Implied licence doctrine, ancillary powers doctrine — Whether opening driver’s door and removing occupant was an unreasonable search — Entry onto driveway permitted but vehicle entry constituted search — Imminent safety threat not objectively reasonable, less intrusive options available — Breath test results excluded<br />Constitution — Charter, ss. 8 and 9 — Warrantless arrest — Whether arrest for impaired driving was supported by reasonable grounds — Dispatch information and odour of alcohol showed consumption, not impairment — No independent observations before arrest — Unlawful arrest and arbitrary detention found — Breath test results excluded<br />Constitution — Charter, ss. 10(a) and 10(b) — Right to counsel, reasons for detention — Whether detainee was informed promptly of reasons and right to counsel — Continued handcuffing and detention without explanation — No right to counsel given during operative period before ASD demand — Breaches found — Breath test results excluded<br />Constitution — Charter, s. 8 — Criminal Code, s. 320.27(1) — ASD demand — Whether ASD demand was made as soon as reasonable suspicion existed — Delay while retrieving ASD and moving to porch, despite recognized lack of arrest grounds — Immediacy requirement not met — Unreasonable search and seizure found — Breath test results excluded
  • 2026-11-10 Ontario (Director, Family Responsibility Office) v. Newman, 2026 ONCJ 682 (CanLII)
    Key Words: Family — Support enforcement — Support arrears — Interjurisdictional support order registered under Interjurisdictional Support Orders Act, 2002 — Child support arrears fixed on default hearing — Periodic and lump sum repayment schedule set — Reporting of address and email required — Default order with committal terms granted<br />Procedure — Default hearings — Onus and powers — Family Responsibility and Support Arrears Enforcement Act, s. 41(9) and (10) — Whether the payor proved inability to pay for valid reasons — Difficulty paying not inability to pay — Inadequate disclosure and adverse inference considered — Default payment terms imposed<br />Family — Income assessment — Gross-up — Self-employed payor operating in cash with no records — Whether claimed income was credible — Income assessed higher to reflect actual earnings — Gross-up applied because no tax paid, Sarafinchin v. Sarafinchin, Prillo v. Homer — Ability to pay found<br />Procedure — Committal orders — Imprisonment for non-payment — Whether committal is required as a last resort to enforce support — Hennessy factors applied — Pattern of avoidance, non-voluntary payments, lack of transparent disclosure — No practical garnishment or execution options — Imprisonment terms ordered for default within 180-day maximum
  • 2026-11-09 Children’s Aid Society of Toronto v. S.P., 2026 ONCJ 678 (CanLII)
    Key Words: Child protection — Information sharing and privacy — Placement assessment disclosure — Whether ss. 291.1 and 292.1 (Child, Youth and Family Services Act, 2017) restrict use and disclosure of historical child protection information about a former child — Disclosure within protection proceedings balanced against privacy safeguards — Caregiver suitability and best interests context emphasised — Motion dismissed<br />Statutory interpretation — Child, Youth and Family Services Act, 2017 — “Prescribed record” under O. Reg. 191/18 — Interpretation of ss. 291.1 and 292.1 in context and purpose — Carve out for records collected through core child protection functions under s. 35(1)(a) to (c) — Harmonious reading with placement assessment obligations under O. Reg. 156/18 — Motion dismissed<br />Procedure — Motions — 14B motion in writing — Sealing and notice request — Whether adult whose sensitive information appears in affidavit should receive notice and whether affidavit should be sealed — Court provides clarification and direction in reasons — No order required for use or disclosure; 14B motion dismissed — Motion dismissed
  • 2026-11-09 Native Child and Family Services of Toronto v. K.H., 2026 ONCJ 680 (CanLII)
    Key Words: Child protection — Protection finding — Risk of physical harm — Child, Youth and Family Services Act, 2017, subclause 74(2)(b)(i) — Whether the child is in need of protection based on risk of physical harm — Real and likely risk assessed on balance of probabilities — Mother’s mental health concerns and parenting capacity considered — Finding made under subclause 74(2)(b)(i)<br />Child protection — Disposition — Custody order to parent — Child, Youth and Family Services Act, 2017, ss. 101, 102 — Whether intervention through a court order is necessary to protect the child in the future — Best interests analysis under the Act applied — Placement with one parent assessed against protection concerns — Custody granted to father under s. 102<br />Child protection — Parenting time — Supervised access — Child, Youth and Family Services Act, 2017, ss. 104, 105 — What parenting time order is in the child’s best interests — Whether the mother’s parenting time should remain supervised — Structured parenting time at supervised centre and at child’s activities — Supervised parenting time ordered with detailed terms<br />Indigenous peoples — Indigenous child — Best interests factors — An Act Respecting First Nations, Inuit and Métis children, Youth and Families, SC 2019, s. 10(3) — How the best interests analysis addresses the child’s Indigenous identity — Child described as having Indigenous identity and affiliation through the mother — Cultural connection and programming considered in parenting arrangements — Cultural connection terms ordered
Ontario Court of Justice