Décisions de la Cour
Une série de jugements de la Cour supérieure de justice, pour la plupart rendus après le 1er octobre 2004, sont affichés sur le site Web de CanLII. Ce site n’est pas une source exhaustive de jugements de la Cour supérieure de justice. La version officielle des motifs de jugement est le document original signé ou l’endossement manuscrit dans le dossier de la Cour. S’il y a une question concernant le contenu d’un jugement, le document original dans le dossier de la Cour l’emporte.
Les jugements ne sont disponibles que dans la langue dans laquelle ils ont été rédigés.
On peut obtenir des copies des jugements de la Cour supérieure de justice en contactant les greffes respectifs où l’affaire a été entendue. Des frais de photocopie sont requis. On peut consulter ces jugements en s’abonnant à un service comme LexisNexis® QuicklawMC, et WestlawNextMDMD Canada.
Abonnez-vous au fil de nouvelles RSS afin de consulter les décisions de la Cour supérieure de justice
- Cour supérieure de justice – Décisions récentes
- Cour supérieure de justice – Cour divisionnaire – Décisions récentes
Cour supérieure de justice – Décisions récentes
-
2026-11-09 Abouzeid v. eXp Realty of Canada Inc et al., 2026 CanLII 119507 (ON SC)
Mots-clés: Procedure — Costs — Offers to settle — Rules of Civil Procedure, r. 57.01 — Whether the offer to settle triggered substantial indemnity costs — Offer to resolve claims through arbitration with costs in the cause and arbitrator jurisdiction over contemplated injunction — No other factors justifying elevated scale — Partial indemnity costs awarded
Procedure — Costs — Fixing costs — Boucher v. Public Accountants Council for the Province of Ontario, 2004 CarswellOnt 2521 (C.A.) — Whether partial indemnity fees were fair and reasonable under r. 57.01 — Court must consider reasonable expectations, not hours times rates — Fees claimed outside range for unsuccessful party — Fees fixed
Procedure — Costs — Reasonableness of steps — Cross-examination and staffing — Whether three-lawyer staffing and time claimed justified the costs sought — Preparation of motion record and preparation for cross-examinations scrutinised — Motion not unduly complex and principles not unsettled — Amount claimed exceeded reasonable expectation — Fees reduced and fixed
Procedure — Costs — Discretion — Comparable amounts — Whether costs should be fixed at the amounts equivalent to the Plaintiff’s own costs outlines — Reliance on Plaintiff’s outlined partial indemnity costs for each motion — Court applies r. 57.01 factors and Boucher principle — Fair and reasonable amounts fixed below amounts sought — Costs fixed payable within 30 days -
2026-11-09 Qusay Abduljaleel v. Desjardins Insurance Company, 2026 CanLII 119502 (ON SC)
Mots-clés: Insurance — Automobile insurance — Statutory Conditions — Claim for additional “top up payment” after property damage settlement — Whether relief from forfeiture should permit claim despite limitation period — No facts supporting equitable relief — Insurer acted promptly and no waiver suggested — Summary judgment for insurer, claim dismissed
Limitation periods — Automobile property damage — O. Reg. 777/93, s. 9(4) under the Insurance Act — Whether action is barred by one-year period running from “happening of the loss” — Mandatory and unambiguous wording for damage to an automobile — Accident date as trigger — Action time-barred, claim dismissed
Limitation periods — Discoverability — Limitations Act, 2002, s. 5(1)(a) — Whether limitation starts when top up payment is denied — Discoverability in this context relates to discoverability of the loss — Plaintiff knew of loss and insurer’s position within about 90 days — Discoverability rejected, claim dismissed
Procedure — Summary judgment — Rules of Civil Procedure, r. 20.04(2)(a) — Whether there is no genuine issue requiring a trial — Parties agree matter can be determined by summary judgment — Transaction and communications documented — Limitation issue determinable on the record — Summary judgment granted, action dismissed -
2026-11-06 Vander Doelen v. Leighway Enterprises Inc., 2026 ONSC 6259 (CanLII)
Mots-clés: Procedure — Security for costs — Rule 56 motion — Rule 56.01(1)(a) ordinarily resident outside Ontario — Whether threshold for security for costs met — Two-stage framework and onus-shifting described, Yaiguaje v. Chevron Corporation cited — Discretionary assessment of justness required — Motion dismissed
Procedure — Security for costs — Delay — Delay in bringing motion for security for costs — Whether delay makes security unjust after litigation expense incurred — Pelz v. Anderson applied, plaintiff incurred significant resources including expert reports — Defendant reasonably knew plaintiff not resident in Ontario earlier — Security for costs refused
Procedure — Security for costs — Frivolous and vexatious — Rule 56.01(1)(e) good reason to believe action frivolous and vexatious — Whether merits justify security where credibility contested — Court declines to weigh merits heavily and cannot make clear finding on record — Credibility issues noted, 2179548 ONTARIO INC. v. 2467925 ONTARIO INC. cited — Security for costs denied
Procedure — Security for costs — Enforcing judgments — Whether ability to enforce Ontario judgment in British Columbia weighs against security — Enforcement of Canadian Judgments and Decrees Act and Reciprocal Enforcement of Judgments Act referenced — Morguard Investments Ltd. v. De Savoye cited on interprovincial enforcement — Discretion informed by likely enforceability — Motion dismissed -
2026-11-06 Nutri Sci 2000 Inc. v. McLean, 2026 ONSC 6263 (CanLII)
Mots-clés: Contracts — Loans and advances — Characterisation of transaction — Whether advances were a personal loan or an investment or business loan — Payment orders marked “Business Loan” and “Investment” — Handwritten note described “short-term loan” with repayment timing — Conflicting evidence on parties’ intentions — Motion for summary judgment dismissed
Procedure — Summary judgment — Rule 20.04, Rules of Civil Procedure — Whether there is no genuine issue requiring a trial — Hryniak framework and “best foot forward” principle — Record insufficient for credibility findings and necessary factual determinations — Enhanced fact-finding powers under r. 20.04(2.1) not used — Motion for summary judgment dismissed
Contracts — Formation of contract — Oral agreement — Whether there was a meeting of the minds on essential terms — Offer, acceptance and consideration requirements — Uncertainty as to repayment terms and whether handwritten notes reflected agreement — Evidence did not establish intention to create a legally binding agreement — Matter left for trial — Motion for summary judgment dismissed
Business associations — Corporate capacity — Agency and disclosure — Whether the Defendant acted personally or as agent for her company — Whether the Plaintiff knew or ought reasonably to have known it was dealing with a corporate entity — Transfers referencing “Star Apple Inc.” as beneficiary — Record unclear on why company was referenced and parties’ intentions — Trial required — Motion for summary judgment dismissed -
2026-11-05 Sweda Farms Ltd. v. Egg Farmers of Ontario, 2026 ONSC 6256 (CanLII)
Mots-clés: Procedure — Costs — Scale of costs — Whether substantial indemnity costs warranted for plaintiffs’ conduct — Substantial indemnity reserved for reprehensible, scandalous and outrageous conduct, Davies v. Clarington (Municipality) — Plaintiffs’ conduct found not to rise to misconduct — Partial indemnity costs awarded
Procedure — Costs — Successful party — Whether defendants entitled to costs where security ordered was 76% of amount claimed — Defendants clearly successful in obtaining substantial security for costs order — Reduced result considered for potential reduction, not disentitlement — Plaintiffs to pay defendants’ costs — Costs awarded
Procedure — Costs — Proportionality — Whether separate counsel caused unnecessary duplication and disproportionate costs — Defendants’ positions and trial costs not identical on a security for costs motion — One motion record and one factum served — Plaintiffs’ differentiated defence required responses — Partial indemnity amounts fixed
Procedure — Costs — Entitlement — Whether Klei Defendants should be denied costs due to minimal visibility — Klei Defendants had their own costs to secure and were entitled to be present — Succeeded along with other defendants — Entitled to costs as a result — Partial indemnity costs awarded
Cour divisionnaire - Décisions récentes
-
2026-11-09 Zandi v. Normar Drywall Inc., 2026 ONSC 6149 (CanLII)
Mots-clés: Contracts — Construction services invoice — Outstanding account — Drywall work at personal residence — Dispute over unpaid balance after credits and payments — Whether judgment for balance owing should stand — Written communications about deductions, credits, HST, and allocation of prior payments considered — Appeal dismissed
Procedure — Procedural fairness — Adjournment — Whether refusing adjournment denied fair opportunity to present case — Compliance with settlement conference production obligations — Electronic copies sought though documents already produced and available through client and court file — Eleventh-hour request and discretion considered — Procedural fairness ground dismissed
Limitation periods — Discoverability — Limitations Act, 2002, ss. 4 and 5 — Did deputy judge err by treating limitation period as commencing when communications ended — Role of ongoing discussions and negotiations in determining when a proceeding is an appropriate means to seek a remedy — Issue not determined as unnecessary — Appeal dismissed
Limitation periods — Acknowledgment of debt — Limitations Act, 2002, s. 13 — Did written text message exchanges constitute clear and unequivocal acknowledgments of debt — Whether debtor must acknowledge precise amount or only debt itself — Continuing acknowledgments up to late April 2022 found despite dispute over quantum — Appeal dismissed -
2026-11-06 Suarez Oria v. Farzan, 2026 ONSC 6054 (CanLII)
Mots-clés: applicability — reserved — temporary — interpretation — writing -
2026-11-04 Clegg v. Carleton Condo Corporation, 2026 ONSC 3094 (CanLII)
Mots-clés: Administrative law — Appeals from tribunal — Question of law, jurisdiction — Condominium Act, 1998, s. 1.46(2) — Questions of law reviewed on correctness — Whether grounds of appeal improperly challenge findings of fact — Tribunal jurisdiction over governance decision to issue an updated PIC considered — Appeal dismissed with costs
Access to information — Condominium records — Board meeting minutes, redaction — Condominium Act, 1998, cl. 55(4)(c) — Whether including a unit owner’s name in minutes violates cl. 55(4)(c) — Minutes as information about a legal dispute, not records relating to specific units or owners — No prohibition on disclosing party names in this context — Appeal dismissed
Access to information — Information Certificates to Owners — Periodic Information Certificate adequacy — Condominium Act, 1998, s. 26.3, s. 11.2, O. Reg. 48/01, s. 11.1 — Whether updated PIC issuance and content contravened prescribed timing, form, and accuracy requirements — Governance issue and mixed fact and law not appealable as question of law — PIC found adequate — Appeal dismissed
Procedure — Costs — Tribunal discretion — Tribunal Rules of Practice, Rule 48.2 — Whether Tribunal erred by referring to prior cases and warnings in fixing costs — Prior caution relevant to unreasonable behaviour and expectations of quantum — No impropriety in considering warnings for repeat litigant — Costs award upheld — Appeal dismissed with costs payable to respondent -
2026-11-04 Platinum Cars Inc. et al v. Motor Vehicle Dealers Act, 2026 ONSC 6212 (CanLII)
Mots-clés: Administrative law — Regulatory licensing — Motor vehicle dealer and salesperson registration — Notice of Proposal to revoke registrations upheld by Tribunal — Whether Appellants were entitled to registration under Motor Vehicle Dealers Act, 2002, s. 6(1)(a)(ii) and s. 6(1)(d)(iii) — Appeal dismissed
Evidence — Appeal — Fresh evidence — Palmer v. The Queen test — Whether repair invoice should be admitted on appeal — Due diligence not shown, no interest of justice — Invoice would not have affected result given other findings — Motion for fresh evidence dismissed
Procedure — Appeals — Appellate standards of review — Housen v. Nikolaisen palpable and overriding error — Whether Tribunal erred in factual findings on BMW coolant issue and adequacy of disclosure and responses — Appeal not a re-weighing of evidence — Ground of appeal dismissed
Administrative law — Remedies and sanctions — Discretionary penalty on appeal — Whether revocation is clearly unfit or reflects an error in principle, College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario v. Peirovy — Tribunal considered alternative sanctions and consumer protection — Revocation upheld, appeal dismissed -
2026-11-02 Brown v. Town of Iroquois Falls, 2026 ONSC 5859 (CanLII)
Mots-clés: Administrative law — Judicial review — Reviewable “decision” — Whether a clerk’s letter enforcing a resolution is subject to judicial review — Clerk lacked authority to amend or rescind a council resolution — Letter characterised as a reminder of the existing process — Application found to relate to the original council resolution — Application dismissed for delay
Procedure — Judicial review — Delay — Whether a seven-year delay warrants dismissal of an application for judicial review — Effective public decision making requires proceedings without excessive delay — Delay characterised as excessive — Court exercised discretion to deny judicial review — Application dismissed for delay
Procedure — Judicial review — Extension of time — Judicial Review Procedures Act, s. 5 — Whether time should be extended where there are apparent grounds for relief and no substantial prejudice — Applicant provided no apparent grounds for relief — No explanation for extraordinary delay accepted — Extension refused — Application dismissed for delay
Procedure — Judicial review — Prejudice — Whether prejudice can be assumed from a many-year delay — Witnesses gone and employees moved on — Council composition changed and record retention not indicated — Finality for resolutions emphasised — Substantial prejudice inferred — Application dismissed for delay