Decisions of the Court
A collection of judgments of the Superior Court of Justice, primarily released after October 1, 2002, is posted on CanLII. The CanLII website is not an exhaustive source of judgments of the Superior Court of Justice. The official version of the reasons for judgment is the signed original or handwritten endorsement in the court file. In the event that there is a question about the content of a judgment, the original in the court file takes precedence.
Judgments are available in the language provided.
Copies of judgments of the Superior Court of Justice can be obtained by contacting the respective court administrative office where the matter was heard. A photocopy charge is payable. Judgments are also available on a number of subscription based services such as LexisNexis® QuicklawTM and WestlawNext® Canada.
Subscribe to the RSS Feeds for Superior Court of Justice Judgments
- Superior Court of Justice Recent Decisions
- Superior Court of Justice Divisional Court Recent Decisions
Superior Court of Justice Recent Decisions
-
2026-11-18 Lee v. Archer, 2026 ONSC 6493 (CanLII)
Key Words: Family — Child support — Financial disclosure — Arrears of child support — Income and financial circumstances central to child support — Best interests of the children considered in ensuring participation — Section 7 expenses identified as remaining issue — Pleadings not struck and matter to proceed to final hearing
Procedure — Family Law Rules — Striking pleadings — Family Law Rules, O. Reg. 114/99, r. 1(8)(c) — Whether pleadings should be struck for disclosure non-compliance — Norris v. Norris three-step process applied — Exceptional remedy and high threshold — Motion to strike refused
Procedure — Disclosure orders — Compliance — Outstanding disclosure under prior order identified — Whether Applicant failed to comply with disclosure order — Further disclosure ordered, including unredacted account statements and Visa records — Timelines imposed for production — Disclosure order enforced
Procedure — Sanctions — Penalty or fine — Family Law Rules, O. Reg. 114/99, r. 1(8)(a.1) — Whether a sanction should be imposed short of striking pleadings — Incomplete and delayed disclosure denounced — Penalty ordered with daily fine for late payment — Penalty imposed
Procedure — Case management — Motions requiring leave — Whether court should case manage matter to final hearing — No further motions without leave of the court — Case Conference directed after disclosure deadline — Process to proceed expeditiously — Case management ordered -
2026-11-18 1914699 Ontario Ltd. v. Metrolinx, 2026 ONSC 6502 (CanLII)
Key Words: Procedure — Discoveries — Refusals and undertakings — Whether issue estoppel applies to prior interlocutory endorsement — Same issue previously decided in motion to remove counsel and compel production — Interlocutory issue estoppel recognised, Lucas-Logan v. Certas, Earley-Kendall v. Sirard — Motion dismissed
Evidence — Solicitor-client privilege — Deemed waiver — Whether reliance pleading triggers deemed waiver of privilege — Discovery questions seeking counsel’s commentary, interpretation, or legal advice about correspondence — One York Street Inc. v. 2360083 Ontario Limited and Roynat Capital Inc. v. Repeatseat Ltd. distinguished — No nexus and no waiver found — Motion dismissed -
2026-11-18 Bhattar v. Sharma, 2026 ONSC 6510 (CanLII)
Key Words: Procedure — Motions — Relief — Motions to set aside Summons to Witness and Certificate of Non-Attendance — Whether the motions were moot because the Summons was spent — Borowski v. Canada (Attorney General) applied — Certificate said to be of advantage and to be relied on — Motion properly before court — Summons set aside, Certificate set aside
Evidence — Standing — Evidentiary motions — Whether a party has standing to move to quash a summons to witness — Seelster Farms Inc. v. Ontario followed — Right of any other party with an interest in summary judgment motion to object — Summons treated as evidentiary motion — Standing found — Summons set aside
Procedure — Court orders — Scheduling orders — Whether triage court endorsement required the Defendants to proceed by motion — 2352392 Ontario v. MSI and UHA Research Society v. Canada (Attorney General) cited — “Scheduling Orders are Orders” — Defendants not entitled to disregard Order by issuing Rule 39.03 Summons — Summons set aside, Certificate set aside
Procedure — Abuse of process — Rules of Civil Procedure, r. 39.03 — Whether issuing and serving the Summons after abandoning the ordered motion was improper — Rule 39.03 does not require leave, but Order directed a motion to determine issue — Ignoring Order constituted an abuse of process — Reference to contempt found unwarranted — Summons set aside, Certificate set aside
Procedure — Orders — Peremptory orders — Whether court should order that breaches of all future court orders are peremptory on the Defendants — Request found unclear as to what was sought, basis for request, and ability to grant relief — Relief refused — Request denied -
2026-11-17 Rosenberg v. Lipman, 2026 ONSC 6438 (CanLII)
Key Words: Estates and wills — Costs in estates litigation — Endorsement on costs — Costs determined under Courts of Justice Act, s. 131 and Rules of Civil Procedure, rule 57 — Costs fixed as all inclusive sums for trustee removal and passing of accounts proceedings — Requests for increased costs considered — Costs awards made in favour of estate trustees
Procedure — Costs — Estates litigation — Whether public policy exception required costs payable out of estate — Application of s. 131 of the Courts of Justice Act and rule 57 — Trustee removal application treated under civil costs regime — Successful responding party entitled to costs — Costs payable personally by unsuccessful party
Procedure — Costs — Offers to settle — Rule 49.13 factors — Whether failure to accept offers more favourable than outcome justified elevated scale — Substantial indemnity basis considered without “reprehensible” conduct — Proportionality and duplication of senior counsel time assessed — Costs fixed below amount claimed — Costs fixed
Trusts — Passing of accounts — Increased costs — Trustee indemnity for reasonably incurred legal costs — Trustee Act, s. 23.1 and entitlement to indemnity applied — Rule 74.18(11) requests for increased costs beyond Tariff C assessed — Voluminous objections largely unsuccessful except compensation — Costs fixed for each passing of accounts application — Increased costs allowed
Trusts — Costs payable — Source of payment — Whether costs should be payable from trust assets or beneficiary’s distributive share — No basis for costs against other beneficiary or other trust — Costs payable from distributive share of estate, then distributive share of trust, then trust assets if insufficient — Allocation between estate and trust accounting applications determined — Payment directions ordered -
2026-11-17 R v. Montana, 2026 ONSC 6465 (CanLII)
Key Words: Criminal and statutory offences — Impaired operation investigations — Refuse to comply — Criminal Code, s. 320.15(1) and s. 320.28(2)(a) — Whether a valid and unequivocal DRE demand was made and communicated — Effect of superfluous words after a demand made in Criminal Code wording — “Lawful compulsion” and refusal consequences discussed, R v. Knox — Appeal allowed, new trial ordered
Statutory interpretation — Meaning of “evaluation” — Regulations — Whether “evaluation” is defined by Evaluation of Impaired Operation (Drugs and Alcohol) Regulations, SOR/2008-196 — Error in creating a definition and relying on DIE manuals — Overlap noted but regulation not the 12-Step DIE — Extrinsic evidence approach rejected, R. v. Takov (ONSC) — Appeal allowed, new trial ordered
Procedure — Summary conviction appeal — Question of law — Remedy — Whether Crown grounds raise a question of law alone where findings of fact not disputed — Question of law described and applied, R. v. Morin, R. v. Luedecke — Focus on legal effect of facts — Remedy of remitting matter back as requested — Appeal allowed, new trial ordered
Superior Court of Justice Divisional Court Recent Decisions
-
2026-11-18 Gelinas v. Ontario Police Review Director et al, 2026 ONSC 6363 (CanLII)
Key Words: Judicial review — Practice and procedure — Motions -
2026-11-18 Yalda Contracting Inc. v. 1014542 Ontario Limited, o/a TRP Construction General Contractors, 2026 ONSC 6475 (CanLII)
Key Words: Construction — Subcontracting disputes — Back charges — Landscaping subcontractor contamination of granular material — General contractor directed paving subcontractor remediation and back charged — Allocation of responsibility for remediation costs on project site — Summary judgment upheld on back charge dispute — Appeal dismissed
Evidence — Summary judgment record — Proof of warranty — Whether evidence established existence or scope of paving subcontractor warranty — Affidavit evidence describing site supervisor belief, not direct warranty terms — No evidence from paving subcontractor or discussions proving warranty — Warranty not proven on record — Appeal dismissed
Contracts — Performance and breach — Opportunity to rectify — Whether contractor must be given reasonable opportunity to correct deficiencies before back charge — Opportunity to rectify treated as duty to mitigate — Fundamental breach exception noted but not established — Bypassing subcontractor disentitled general contractor to claim costs — Appeal dismissed
Contracts — Remedies — Set-off — Whether remediation costs could be set-off against amounts owing — No damages owing by general contractor to subcontractor, nothing to set off — Lack of evidence on timing necessity or remediation costs — Set-off argument rejected on facts — Appeal dismissed -
2026-11-18 Rypnicki v. Administrator Ontario Works Regional, 2026 ONSC 6486 (CanLII)
Key Words: Pensions and social benefits — Social assistance — Ontario Works overpayment — Assessment and recovery of overpayment under Ontario Works Act, 1997, s. 19(1) — Recipient’s federal benefits leading to ineligibility and overpayment — Social Benefits Tribunal decision upheld on overpayment consequences — Appeal dismissed
Procedure — Statutory appeal — Questions of law only — Ontario Works Act, 1997, s. 36 — Whether challenge to tribunal finding on understanding obligations is an impermissible factual appeal — Correctness standard stated while factual findings not appealable — No reviewable legal error in fact-finding process — Appeal dismissed
Rights and freedoms — Human rights — Duty to accommodate — Human Rights Code — Whether tribunal erred in law on duty to accommodate where issue not properly raised — Notice of Appeal and reconsideration request did not identify accommodation — Tribunal not required to decide argument not before it — Ground dismissed
Pensions and social benefits — Social assistance — Discretion to collect overpayment — Ontario Works, Policy directive 9.3, Recovery of Overpayments — Whether tribunal limited analysis to financial hardship only — Reasons read as whole show consideration of role, hardship, and circumstances — One-year delay in collection considered fair — No legal error established
Procedure — Reasons — Reconsideration decision — Whether reconsideration reasons were inadequate — Full hearing and detailed initial reasons provided — Reconsideration reasons responsive and comprehensible in context — Ground dismissed, appeal dismissed -
2026-11-17 Rasul et al v. Whelan, 2026 ONSC 6323 (CanLII)
Key Words: inclusive — fixed — writing — motion — denied -
2026-11-17 Canadian Pacific Railway Company v. Teamsters Canada Rail Conference, 2026 ONSC 6473 (CanLII)
Key Words: Administrative law — Judicial review — Reasonableness — Vavilov framework — Whether the award was transparent, intelligible and justified — Failure of rationality internal to the reasoning process alleged — Deference to CROA arbitrators noted — Decision found unreasonable in light of legal and factual constraints — Application granted
Labour and employment — Labour arbitration — Management rules — KVP and Irving test — Whether the arbitrator failed to conduct a “delicate, case-by-case balancing” of interests — Unilateral drug and alcohol measures in safety critical and safety sensitive positions — Privacy and lawful off-duty activity weighed against safety interests — Matter remitted for redetermination
Rights and freedoms — Charter factors — Privacy — Whether Charter cases were necessarily irrelevant to the KVP reasonableness analysis — KVP test distinguished from Charter analysis, but “undeniable overlap” recognised — Irving consideration of Charter cases on employee privacy noted — Charter factors may inform balancing exercise — Matter remitted for redetermination
Procedure — Remedies — Judicial review — Remittal — Whether the court should declare the measures reasonable or remit to the arbitrator — Usual remedy of remitting applied under Vavilov — Same arbitrator retained given extensive hearing and untainted factual findings — Decision set aside and remitted for redetermination — Application granted