Court of Appeal for Ontario

Decisions of the Court of Appeal – 1998

Releasing Decisions of the Court of Appeal

June
Title Date Released Format
Dinicola v. Huang & Danczkay Properties June 19, 1998 HTML
Hanis v. Teevan, et. al. June 18, 1998 HTML
Nespolon v. Snider June 24, 1998 HTML
R. v. Trombley June 29, 1998 HTML
Tannous v. Donaghue June 8, 1998 HTML

July
Title Date Released Format
3173763 Canada Inc. Ronald v. Kemp and McMillan Binch July 9, 1998 HTML
859587 Ontario Ltd. v. Starmark Property Management Ltd. July 27, 1998 HTML
872889 Ontario Ltd. v. Iacovoni July 3, 1998 HTML
913719 Ontario Ltd. v. Mississauga (City) July 21, 2000 HTML
Choquette v. Choquette July 28, 1998 HTML
Clark v. Peterborough Utilities Commission, et. al. July 15, 1998 HTML
Corporation of the Canadian Civil Liberties Association v. Canada Attorney General) July 9, 1998 HTML
Direk v. Anthony Dixon, et. al. July 9, 1998 HTML
Evenchick v. Ottawa (City) July 20, 1998 HTML
Farquar v. Paquin July 27, 1998 HTML
Findlay et. al. v. Holmes July 3, 1998 HTML
Glassworkers Social Club v. Forestgate Leasing Inc. July 3, 1998 HTML
Gottardo Properties (Dome) Inc. v. Toronto (City) July 29, 1998 HTML
Grygorcewicz v. Agar July 31, 1998 HTML
Metropolitan Toronto Condominium Corp. No. 935 v. Nourhaghighi July 29, 1998 HTML
Murano, et. al. v. Bank of Montreal & Peat, Marwick, Thorne July 14, 1998 HTML
Polish National Union of Canada Incorporated-Mutual Benefit Society v. Palais Royale Ltd., et. al. July 14, 1998 HTML
R. v. Blakeley July 17, 1998 HTML
R. v. Fort Erie (Town) July 15, 1998 HTML
R. v. Huang July 14, 1998 HTML
R. v. Lee July 10, 1998 HTML
R. v. McCullough July 14, 1998 HTML
R. v. McDonald July 21, 1998 HTML
R. v. W., D. July 29, 1998 HTML
R. v. W., S. July 8, 1998 HTML
Rutherford v. Hickson July 28, 1998 HTML
Sidaplex-Plastic Suppliers Inc. v. Elta Group Inc., et. al. July 13, 1998 HTML
Soper et. al. v. Southcott et. al. July 6, 1998 HTML
Sun Life Trust Company et. al. July 3, 1998 HTML
Walsh v. Walsh July 20, 1998 HTML
Williams v. Motorola Ltd. July 8, 1998 HTML

August
Title Date Released Format
Bank of Montreal v. Minaki International Resort Corporation August 26, 1998 HTML
Bannister v. General Motors of Canada August 27, 1998 HTML
Bradley v. Carleton Electric Ltd. August 11, 1998 HTML
Brooks v. Brooks August 7, 1998 HTML
Budd v. Gentra Inc. et. al. August 4, 1998 HTML
Davies, Ward & Beck v. Baker and McKenzie August 17, 1998 HTML
Dawson et. al. v. Rexcraft Storage and Warehouse Inc. et. al. August 11, 1998 HTML
Gibson v. Louis McNichol Trucking Ltd. August 27, 1998 HTML
Gonsalves v. Catholic Church Extension Society of Canada August 27, 1998 HTML
Hulme v. Cadillac Fairview Corporation Ltd. August 12, 1998 HTML
Kiani v. Minto Developments Inc. August 26, 1998 HTML
Kowaleski v. Ontario August 5, 1998 HTML
MacAlpine v. Stratford General Hospital August 14, 1998 HTML
Martin v. Goldfarb August 26, 1998 HTML
Matuszek v. McCormack, et. al. August 12, 1998 HTML
McNamara v. Ontario Racing Commission August 13, 1998 HTML
Ontario Secondary School Teachers’ Federation v. Barton August 24, 1998 HTML
Orchover v. Wright August 14, 1998 HTML
R. v. Gassyt August 12, 1998 HTML
R. v. Gendey August 21, 1998 HTML
R. v. Kelly August 14, 1998 HTML
R. v. Ruzic August 28, 1998 HTML
R. v. Stuckless August 10, 1998 HTML
Ritchie v. Whitmell August 27, 1998 HTML
Smillie v. Smillie August 14, 1998 HTML
United States of America v. Kwok August 4, 1998 HTML
Uvalde Investment Company v. West End Development Corporation August 27, 1998 HTML
Wolkow v. Dunnell August 13, 1998 HTML

September
Title Date Released Format
1101644 Ontario Limited v. Jacobs September 10, 1998 HTML
710357 Ontario Limited v. Penetanguishene (Township) September 8, 1998 HTML
Ajax (Town) v. National Automobile, et al., Workers Union of Canada September 30, 1998 HTML
Appleyard v. Appleyard September 16, 1998 HTML
Bayer Aktiengesellschaft v. Apotex Inc. September 25, 1998 HTML
Bruce (Township) v. Ontario (Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing) September 4, 1998 HTML
Campanaro v. Kim September 3, 1998 HTML
Canadian Pacific Limited v. Ontario (Minister of Revenue) September 10, 1998 HTML
Cass v. Seidel September 21, 1998 HTML
Cooksville Steel Limited v. Schmidt September 11, 1998 HTML
Coopers Lybrand Limited v. National Bank of Canada September 1, 1998 HTML
Cousineau v. Roman Catholic Episcopal Corporation September 29, 1998 HTML
Dabbs v. Sun Life Assurance Company of Canada September 14, 1998 HTML
Drees v. Dominion of Canada General Insurance Company September 25, 1998 HTML
Fitzsimmons v. McCauley September 16,1998 HTML
Folkes v. Greensleeves Publishing Limited September 10, 1998 HTML
Follows v. Follows September 10, 1998 HTML
Forest City Linen Supply Limited v. Wales September 21, 1998 HTML
Friedmann Equity Developments Inc. v. Final Note Limited September 9, 1998 HTML
Grey Condominium Corporation No. 18 v. Collingwood (Township) September 16, 1998 HTML
Guttman v. Vaillancourt September 23, 1998 HTML
Hum v. Man September 29, 1998 HTML
Irwin v. Irwin September 11, 1998 HTML
Johnson v. Athletics Canada September 23, 1998 HTML
Kuban v. Royal Bank of Canada September 24, 1998 HTML
Lang v. Kligerman September 18, 1998 HTML
Lewis v. Traders General Insurance Company September 17, 1998 HTML
McLaughlin v. Ultramar Ltd. September 25, 1998 HTML
Mete v. Guardian Insurance Company of Canada September 25, 1998 HTML
Mori v. Thomas September 24, 1998 HTML
Oger v. Chiefscope Incorporated September 21, 1998 HTML
Patel v. Rizzo September 21, 1998 HTML
Picavet v. Paul September 11, 1998 HTML
R. v. B., A.R. September 9, 1998 HTML
R. v. B., J. September 18, 1998 HTML
R. v. B., J. September 24, 1998 HTML
R. v. Bellamy September 21, 1998 HTML
R. v. Brooks September 30, 1998 HTML
R. v. Camacho September 10, 1998 HTML
R. v. Clarke September 9, 1998 HTML
R. v. Collings September 14, 1998 HTML
R. v. Dimitriadis September 18, 1998 HTML
R. v. Duong September 29, 1998 HTML
R. v. Forrest September 23, 1998 HTML
R. v. Groot September 14, 1998 HTML
R. v. Howes September 21, 1998 HTML
R. v. Laws September 9, 1998 HTML
R. v. Leger September 11, 1998 HTML
R. v. Marks September 24, 1998 HTML
R. v. Moore September 16, 1998 HTML
R. v. Nisbet September 28, 1998 HTML
R. v. R., J. September 22, 1998 HTML
R. v. R., S. September 14, 1998 HTML
R. v. Samra September 23, 1998 HTML
R. v. T., L.E. September 15, 1998 HTML
R. v. Thibeault September 17, 1998 HTML
R. v. Vincent September 11, 1998 HTML
R. v. Vucetic September 11, 1998 HTML
R. v. W., S.R. September 24, 1998 HTML
Reichmann v. Vered September 21,1998 HTML
Ryan (Re) September 21, 1998 HTML
Shuster v. Goldberg September 28, 1998 HTML
Stuart v. Hutchins September 14, 1998 HTML
Tsaoussis v. Baetz September 2, 1998 HTML
United States of America v. Friedland September 23, 1998 HTML
Wainbee Limited v. Trinova Canada Inc. September 2, 1998 HTML
Workers’ Compensation Board v. Mitchinson September 3, 1998 HTML
Wright v. Jones September 11, 1998 HTML

October
Title Date Released Format
Agway Metals Inc. v. Fresh Springs Investment International October 22, 1998 HTML
Algonquin Wildlands League v. Ontario (Minister of Natural Resources) October 27, 1998 HTML
Carleton Condominium Corporation No. 97 v. Coscan Development Corporation October 23, 1998 HTML
Carleton Condominium Corporation No. 441 v. Carleton Condominium Corporation No. 441 October 30, 1998 HTML
CIBC Mortgage Inc. v. Sagl October 16, 1998 HTML
Coughlin v. Comery October 14, 1998 HTML
Dr. Kibale v. Ontario October 21, 1998 HTML
Eagleson v. Dowbiggan October 1, 1998 HTML
Etmanski v. Magmun Glass Inc. October 8, 1998 HTML
Flaska (Re) October 20, 1998 HTML
Gagne v. Silcorp Limited October 21, 1998 HTML
Glassman v. Honda Canada Inc. October 29, 1998 HTML
Goodyear Canada Inc. v. Burnhamthorpe Square Inc. October 29, 1998 HTML
Graci (Trustee of) v. Fletcher October 14, 1998 HTML
G.S. Wark Limited v. 949590 Ontario Inc. October 9, 1998 HTML
Hatch Associates Ltd. v. Dual Removal Systems Limited October 23, 1998 HTML
Health One Inc. v. Dr. Leu October 22, 1998 HTML
Hi-Plus Development Ltd. v. Boscarino October 30, 1998 HTML
Household Realty Corporation Limited v. Dirks October 21, 1998 HTML
Kalkinis v. Allstate Insurance Company of Canada October 30, 1998 HTML
Kreutner (Re) October 15, 1998 HTML
Lake (Re) October 28, 1998 HTML
Lakefield (Village) v. Black October 9, 1998 HTML
Logan v. Hines October 20, 1998 HTML
Manulife Bank of Canada v. Kelly October 8, 1998 HTML
Maple Leaf Foods Inc. v. Schneider Corporation October 20, 1998 HTML
Marier c. Lester October 27, 1998 HTML
McAllister v. Dunsmith International Inc. October 22, 1998 HTML
McQuillan v. Native Inter-Tribal Housing Co-Operative Inc. October 27, 1998 HTML
Moriarity v. Sarnia (City) October 8, 1998 HTML
Nicholas v. Anderson October 2, 1998 HTML
O’Brien v. Shantz October 15, 1998 HTML
Osborne v. Ontario October 29, 1998 HTML
Poliacik v. Wunsche October 28, 1998 HTML
Propulsion Capital Inc. v. Goldstein October 2,1998 HTML
R. v. A., H. October 23, 1998 HTML
R. v. Badio October 6, 1998 HTML
R. v. Braithwaite October 1, 1998 HTML
R. v. C., W. October 10, 1998 HTML
R. v. D., D. October 7, 1998 HTML
R. v. Daniels October 28, 1998 HTML
R. v. Day October 29, 1998 HTML
R. v. Downey October 29, 1998 HTML
R. v. G., A. October 8, 1998 HTML
R. v. James October 23, 1998 HTML
R. v. M., B. October 27, 1998 HTML
R. v. M., R. October 2, 1998 HTML
R. v. McCarnan October 16, 1998 HTML
R. v. Nyman October 14, 1998 HTML
R. v. Orme October 29, 1998 HTML
R. v. Prelai October 16, 1998 HTML
R. v. Rathwell October 19, 1998 HTML
R. v. Russo October 16, 1998 HTML
R. v. S., A. October 15, 1998 HTML
R. v. Seed October 28, 1998 HTML
R. v. Smug October 26, 1998 HTML
R. v. Surujlall October 16, 1998 HTML
R. v. Tahirkhelli October 8, 1998 HTML
R. v. Thompson October 1, 1998 HTML
R. v. Walsh October 26, 1998 HTML
R. v. Yager Jr. October 10, 1998 HTML
Re/Max Chartered Realty Inc. v. Apollo Real Estate Limited October 22, 1998 HTML
Royal Bank of Canada v. Divito October 22, 1998 HTML
Rudco Insulation Limited v. Toronto Sanitary Inc. October 15, 1998 HTML
Slokker Canada Corp. v. Horth October 16, 1998 HTML
Smith v. College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario October 28, 1998 HTML
State Farm Fire and Casualty Company v. Royal Insurance of Canada October 30, 1998 HTML
Stonehocker v. King October 2, 1998 HTML
Technorag Ltd. v. Atomic Energy Canada Limited October 1, 1998 HTML
Toronto (City) v. Whitty October 28, 1998 HTML
Trotter v. Trotter October 29, 1998 HTML
Varma v. Rozenberg October 21, 1998 HTML
Wilton v. Genik October 19, 1998 HTML
Wurster v. Universal Environmental Services Inc. October 1, 1998 HTML
Zinto Properties Limited v. Royalbay Investments Limited October 14, 1998 HTML

November
Title Date Released Format
825469 Ontario Limited v. Davidson November 4, 1998 HTML
Bezdziecki v. Allstate Insurance Company of Canada November 23, 1998 HTML
Bratton v. Sort Production Products Ltd. November 20, 1998 HTML
Braun Estate v. Zenair Ltd. November 19, 1998 HTML
Canbev Sales & Marketing Inc. v. Natco Trading Corporation November 25, 1998 HTML
Cole v. Cole November 12, 1998 HTML
Cornish v. J.I. Denure(Chatham) Limited November 26, 1998 HTML
Credit Suisse Canada v. 1133 Yonge Street Holdings Limited November 2, 1998 HTML
Deb v. American Life Insurance Company November 26, 1998 HTML
Dennis v. Wilson November 23, 1998 HTML
Doussept v. Canada Post Corporation November 4, 1998 HTML
Findlater v. Lumsden Brothers Limited November 4, 1998 HTML
Fraser & Beatty v. Domowicz November 24, 1998 HTML
Glenarda Developments Limited v. Pinheiro November 30, 1998 HTML
Hasan v. Metropolitan Condominium Corporation No. 853 November 2, 1998 HTML
Hodkin v. Bigley November 19, 1998 HTML
Interport Sufferance Warehouse Limited v. Roadway Express (Canada) Inc. November 9, 1998 HTML
Kentucky Fried Chicken Canada v. Scott’s Food Services Inc. November 2, 1998 HTML
Kopriva v. Merrill Lynch Canada Incorporated November 30, 1998 HTML
KPMG Inc. v. Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce November 16, 1998 HTML
Kucor Construction & Developments & Associates v. Canada Life Assurance Company November 13, 1998 HTML
Linchris Homes Limited v. Construction Ravin Boise Inc. November 4, 1998 HTML
Lindsay v. Toronto Transit Commission November 16, 1998 HTML
Lineal Group Inc.v.Atlantis Canadian Distributors Inc. November 3, 1998 HTML
Medalist Holdings Limited v. General Electric Capital Equipment Finance Inc. November 4, 1998 HTML
Metropolitan Toronto Police Services Board v. Dr. Young November 13, 1998 HTML
Murphy v. Little Cabaret Inc. November 17, 1998 HTML
Onisiforou v. Rose November 13, 1998 HTML
Ontario v. Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan Board November 19, 1998 HTML
Passmore Gates Development Ltd. v. Chung November 6, 1998 HTML
Peixeiro v. Haberman November 3, 1998 HTML
Piko v. Hudson’s Bay Company November 19, 1998 HTML
Pirpamer v. Zanette November 25, 1998 HTML
Pollastro v. Pollastro November 17, 1998 HTML
Poolton v. Paci November 27, 1998 HTML
R. v. 974649 Ontario Inc. November 13, 1998 HTML
R. v. Ali November 20, 1998 HTML
R. v. B., J.S. November 16, 1998 HTML
R. v. Boutcher November 19, 1998 HTML
R. v. Brennan Paving Construction Ltd. November 23, 1998 HTML
R. v. Chan November 6, 1998 HTML
R. v. D., G.D. November 20, 1998 HTML
R. v. Higgins November 20, 1998 HTML
R. v. Kennedy November 18, 1998 HTML
R. v. M., M. November 12, 1998 HTML
R. v. M., W.M. November 20, 1998 HTML
R. v. Pewngam November 6, 1998 HTML
R. v. Pilon November 18, 1998 HTML
R. v. Rosenthal November 2, 1998 HTML
R. v. Ruttan November 16, 1998 HTML
R. v. Sagoe November 12, 1998 HTML
R. v. Wells November 5, 1998 HTML
R. v. Young November 6, 1998 HTML
Ram Industrial Equip. (Toronto) Ltd. v. Kolson November 6, 1998 HTML
Richter and Partners Inc. v. Hees International Bancorp Inc. November 13, 1998 HTML
Rutherford v. Ontario November 26, 1998 HTML
Sun Life Assurance Company v. York Ridge Developments Limited November 25, 1998 HTML
Talquin Development Company v. CTI Corp. November 5, 1998 HTML
Tremblay v. Tremblay November 6, 1998 HTML
Ublansky v. Barranca November 24, 1998 HTML
United States of America v. Friedland November 27, 1998 HTML
Vergos v. Chateau Insurance Management Inc. November 2, 1998 HTML
Wellington Condominium Corporation No. 70 November 26, 1998 HTML
Wine v. Fisher November 18, 1998 HTML
Woods v. Robertson November 12, 1998 HTML

December
Title Date Released Format
2855-2578 Quebec Inc. v. YM Inc. (Sales) December 9, 1998 HTML
Asea Brown Boveri Inc. v. Transelectrix Technology Inc. December 11, 1998 HTML
Airst v. Airst December 10, 1998 HTML
Beechwood Cemetery Company v. Graham December 17, 1998 HTML
Beechwood Company v. Graham December 17, 1998 HTML
Bezanson v. Falle December 23, 1998 HTML
Bhaduria v. CITY-TV – A Division of Chum Televisions Group December 7, 1998 HTML
Bootsma v. Heide December 10, 1998 HTML
Botterill v. Schuringa December 10, 1998 HTML
Brown v. Durham (Municipality) Police Service Board December 15, 1998 HTML
Canada Trustco Mortgage Company v. Tandon December 7, 1998 HTML
Coopers & Lybrand Limited. v. Golden Quail Management December 10, 1998 HTML
Danyluk v. Ainsworth Technologies Inc. December 2, 1998 HTML
Edwards (Re) December 18, 1998 HTML
Ferrel v. Ontario December 7, 1998 HTML
Gallo v. Beber December 22, 1998 HTML
Hall v. Darborough December 18, 1998 HTML
Hopton v. Pamajewon December 9, 1998 HTML
Howe v. 625362 Ontario Limited December 11, 1998 HTML
Huang & Danczkay Limited v. Board of Regents of Victoria University December 17, 1998 HTML
Ioannou v. Jurian Investments December 18, 1998 HTML
Kaczmarczyk v. Kaczmarczyk December 23, 1998 HTML
Law Society of Upper Canada v. Rajagopol December 21, 1998 HTML
Law Society of Upper Canada v. Toronto Dominion Bank December 7, 1998 HTML
Lukowaski v. Hatch Associates Ltd. December 21, 1998 HTML
Maidstone (Township) v. Loosemore Excavating Inc. December 2, 1998 HTML
Maygar v. Maygar December 11, 1998 HTML
Morton v. Rabito December 10, 1998 HTML
Mutual Life Assurance Company of Canada v. Peat Marwick December 7, 1998 HTML
Noseworthy v. Riverside Pontiac-Buick Ltd. December 21, 1998 HTML
O’Brien v. National Rubber Inc. December 22, 1998 HTML
Perez v. Governing Council of the Salvation Army in Canada December 9, 1998 HTML
Pertronics Technology Inc. v. Copeland December 7, 1998 HTML
R. v. Adams December 14, 1998 HTML
R. v. Broomfield December 1, 1998 HTML
R. v. G., J. December 3, 1998 HTML
R. v. Hayman December 4, 1998 HTML
R. v. Jamieson December 15, 1998 HTML
R. v. M., K. A. December 16, 1998 HTML
R. v. Koh December 30, 1998 HTML
R. v. Miller December 22, 1998 HTML
R. v. Redekopp December 23, 1998 HTML
R. v. Skinner December 29, 1998 HTML
R. v. Veley December 22, 1998 HTML
R. v. W., E. December 8, 1998 HTML
R. v. W., M. December 23, 1998 HTML
R. v. White December 22, 1998 HTML
R. v. Wilson December 23, 1998 HTML
R. v. Young December 29, 1998 HTML
Rachiele v. Rachiele December 11, 1998 HTML
Ramcharitar v. Ramcharitar December 9, 1998 HTML
Religious Hospitallers of St. Joseph Housing Corporation v. Regional Assessment Commissioner, Region 1 December 17, 1998 HTML
Religious Hospitallers of St. Joseph of Cornwall, Ontario v. Regional Assessment Commissioner, Region 1 December 17, 1998 HTML
Religious Hospitallers of St. Joseph Cornwall, Ontario v. Regional Assessment Commissioner, Region 1 December 17, 1998 HTML
Richard v. Bell Canada December 2, 1998 HTML
Shoom, In Trust v. Great-West Lifeco Inc. December 23, 1998 HTML
Staltari Realty Corporation v. Colliers Macaulay Nicolls (Ontario) Inc. December 3, 1998 HTML
State Mortgage Corporation v. Trecapelli December 14, 1998 HTML
Suresh v. Canada December 15, 1998 HTML
Szeckett v. Huang December 10, 1998 HTML
Tran v. Ramlochen December 23, 1998 HTML
V.K. Mason Construction Ltd. v. Canadian General Insurance Group Limited December 17, 1998 HTML
Whaling (Re) December 18, 1998 HTML
Winfair Holdings (Lagoon City) Limited v. Simcoe Condominium Corporation No. 46 December 1, 1998 HTML
This website is maintained by the Judges' Library. Website Policies
to top