Decisions of the Court of Appeal – 2000

Releasing Decisions of the Court of Appeal

January

February

March

April

May

June

July

  • 1039198 Ontario Inc. v. Ash Pharmacies Inc. (July 4, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Berg v. Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Company (July 21, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Bongiardina v. Vaughan (City) (July 26, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Buchanan v. Gan Canada Insurance Company (July 13, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Campitelli v. Ajax (Town) (July 11, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Dwyer v. Cavalluzzo (July 10, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Entrop v. Imperial Oil Limited (July 21, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • F., M. v. Dr. Sutherland (July 5, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Falkiner v. Ontario (July 24, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • I.W.A.-Canada, Local 2693 v. Longlac Wood Industries Inc. (July 13, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Kordish v. Innotech Multimedia Corporation (July 10, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • London Life Insurance Company v. Dubruil Brothers Employees Association (July 13, 2000) (Revised September 8, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Ontario (Family Responsibility Office) v. Total Link International (July 21, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Ottawa Carleton Credit Union Limited v. Walsworth (July 14, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Pate’s Variety Inc. v. Advanced Management Enterprises Limited (July 12, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. A., R.H. (July 13, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Ahmad (July 19, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Alkhouri (July 27, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Ayala (July 14, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. B., G. (July 28, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Bates (July 11, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Brown (July 10, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Brown (July 13, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Clay (July 31, 2000) HTMLPDF; Summary of judgment HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Fudge (July 27, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Hirlemann (July 7, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Koch (July 14, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Levesque (July 27, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Linden (July 31, 2000) (Revised August 4, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. M., C. (July 31, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. MacDonald (July 13, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Masse (July 19, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Parker (July 31, 2000) HTMLPDF; Summary of judgment HTMLPDF
  • R. v. S., D. (July 13, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Stephens (July 11, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. V., W. (July 28, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Vancrey (August 18, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Yaworski (July 13, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Yip (July 27, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Rathwell v. Hershey Canada Inc. (July 7, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Roberts v. Morana (July 20, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Sloan v. York Region District School Board (July 25, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Spasic v. Imperial Tobacco Limited (July 21, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Sun Life Assurance Company of Canada v. National Automobile, Aerospace, Transportation and General Workers Union of Canada (CAW-Canada) (July 13, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Teepee Excavation & Grading Ltd. v. Niran Construction Ltd. (July 7, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Vaz-Oxlade v. Volkenstein (July 24, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Watson v. Southam Inc. (July 7, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Wei v. Dales (July 25, 2000) HTMLPDF

August

  • Felker v. Cunningham (August 29, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Figueroa v. Canada (Attorney General) (August 16, 2000) HTMLPDF; Summary of judgment HTMLPDF
  • Guiney v. Toronto (City) (August 21, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Harris v. Harris (August 2, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Harroun (Litigation guardian of) v. Turriff (August 21, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Kreutner v. Waterloo Oxford Co-Operative Inc. (Aug 18, 2000) (Revised September 7, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Lang v. McKenna (August 14, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • McCann v. J.J. Barnicke Limited (August 25, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Moin v. Blue Mountains (Town) (August 22, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • O’Brien v. McNabb (August 17, 2000) (Revised August 22, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Oldfield v. Transamerica Life Insurance Company of Canada (August 1, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • P.I.A. Investments Inc. v. Deerhurst Limited Partnership (August 1, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. B., G., et al. (August 10, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Blair (August 23, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Djekic (August 22, 2000) (Revised September 11, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Emans (August 15, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Habib (August 18, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Mould (August 22, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Nelles (August 18, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Patenaude (August 18, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. R., P. T. (August 11, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Smith (August 24, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Royal Bank of Canada v. 951911 Ontario Limited (August 28, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Strong v. Kisbee (Estate Trustee) (August 1, 2000) HTMLPDF

September

  • Bank of Montreal v. Korico Enterprises Limited (September 8, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Bank of Nova Scotia v. 1241139 Ontario Limited (September 5, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Bibieffe International Holding B.V. v. York Region Condominium Corporation No. 838 (September 29, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Canada Trust v. Burden (September 12, 2000) (Revised October 16, 2000)HTMLPDF
  • Canadian Premier Holdings Ltd. v. Winterthur Canada Financial Corporation (Supplementary Reasons) (September 8, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Chisos Investment Company v. 790572 Ontario Limited (September 8, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Cooper v. Whyne (September 28, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Cooperators Insurance Company v. AXA Boreal Assurances (September 25, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Corporacion Transnacional de Inversiones, et al v. Stet International (September 15, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Dysart (Municipality) v. Reeve (September 26, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Eberts v. Carleton Condominium Corporation No. 396 (October 16, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Falkiner v. Ontario (September 22, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Fellowes, McNeil v. Kansa General International Insurance Company Ltd. (September 11, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Fellowes, McNeil v. Kansa General International Insurance Company Ltd. (Addendum) (November 9, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Gilbert v. Commissioner of the Ontario Provincial Police Force (September 25, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Kapuscinski v. Aristos Capital Corporation (September 22, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Lana International Ltd. v. Menasco Aerospace Ltd. (September 7, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Landry (Re) (September 6, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Leavoy v. Leavoy (September 20, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Lecour v. North American Life Assurance Company (September 19, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Leo Alarie and Sons Limited v. Ontario (September 13, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Lyons v. Multari (September 21, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Mathura v. Scarborough General Hospital (September 28, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Nunziata v. Wong (September 15, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Ontario v. Grievance Settlement Board (September 18, 2000) (Revised January 8, 2001) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. B., J. (September 6, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Balkissoon (September 15, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Brennan (September 26, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Clifford (September 12, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Davy (September 25, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Dosch (September 6, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Dumont (September 19, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Finnessey (September 11, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Gagnon (September 15, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Godfree (September 15, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. H., A. (September 7, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Hackert (September 22, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Hall (September 1, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Hillier (September 20, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Johnston (September 27, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Leming (September 27, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. McDonald (September 11, 2000) (Revised November 10, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Nelson (September 6, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Patterson (September 1, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Pengelly (September 20, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Provo (September 6, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Pupovic (September 8, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Shchavinsky (September 13, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Sweeney (September 25, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Syed (September 25, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Smyth v. Waterfall (September 13, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Tauber v. Tauber (Addendum) (September 13, 2000) HTMLPDF

October

  • 114567 Canada Limited v. Attwell (October 18, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Arbelaez v. Vickar (Octobrer 27, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Attorney General of Canada v. Juliar (October 6, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Benedict v. Ontario (October 13, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Bonofoco v. Dowd (October 17, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Carom v. Bre-X Minerals Ltd. (October 31, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Certa v. Congo Inc. (October 13, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Devgan v. Jiwani (October 26, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Eberts v. Carleton Condominium Corporation No. 396 (October 16, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Finlayson v. Roberts (October 17, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Godonoaga v. Khatambakhsh (October 18, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Huras v. Primerica Financial Services Ltd. (October 16, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Huron (County) v. Service Employees’ Union Local 210 (October 25, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • John Ziner Lumber Ltd. v. Kotov (October 17, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Krisko v. Krisko (October 26, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Lavallie v. Kingston Psychiatric Hospital (October 5, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Longo v. Maciorowski (October 3, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Migos v. Zurich Indemnity Company of Canada (October 5, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Murphy v. Lloyd’s of London (October 24, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Nunziata v. Wong (October 20, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Ontario v. Hamilton Health Sciences Corporation (October 23, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Police Retirees of Ontario Incorporated v. Ontario Municipal Employees’ Retirement Board (October 5, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • PSC Foods Limited v. Wong (October 23, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Bedard (October 27, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. C., D.W. (October 11, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. E., S. (October 23, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Gogo (October 5, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Garrod (October 4, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Hersi (October 30, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. L., J. (October 17, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Lauzon (October 26, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Meshko (October 16, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Perry (October 19, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Pritchard (October 4, 2000) (Revised October 25, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Schell (October 3, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Schwarz (October 20, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • S.M.J.M. v. Attorney General of Canada (October 23, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Siddiqui v. Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (October 4, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Society of Composers, Authors and Music Publishers of Canada v. Armitage (October 27, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Valliquette v. Belnet Communications Inc. (October 18, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Vanderlugt v. Kuyumcuoglu (October 23, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Wittnauer International v. Federal Express Canada Ltd. (October 20, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Wong v. 407527 Ontario Limited (October 23, 2000) HTMLPDF

November

  • 1013799 Ontario Limited v. Kent Line International Limited (November 8, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • 1224948 Ontario Ltd. v. 448332 Ontario Limited (November 14, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Bank of Montreal v. Giannotti (November 10, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Barrick Gold Corporation v. Ontario (November 21, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Brownell v. Tannahill (November 30, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Canada v. Curragh Inc. (November 6, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Canadian Union of Public Employees v. Ontario (November 21, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Coulter v. Canadian National Railway (November 15, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Creasor v. Cadillac Fairview Corporation (November 10, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Deloitte & Touche v. Meramvaliotakis (November 9, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Dincor Realty Group v. Re/Max Apex Realty (November 3, 2000) (Revised November 8, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Girsberger v. Kresz (November 10, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Hamilton Discount Corporation Ltd. v. Smith (November 1, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Honey Grove Estates Inc. v. Diversey Lever Canada (November 6, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Kinbauri Gold Corporation v. Iamgold International African Mining Gold Corporation (November 9, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Johnson v. Brampton (City) (November 14, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Lachapelle v. Lachapelle (November 15, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Lan Associates XVIII L.P. v. Bank of Nova Scotia (November 2, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Lee v. 1071397 Ontario Inc. (November 23, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Machin v. Tomlinson (November 20, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Marchand v. The Public General Hospital Society of Chatham (November 27, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Martin v. Listowel Memorial Hospital (November 1, 2000) (Revised January 3, 2001) HTMLPDF
  • Mississauga (City) v. Greater Toronto Airports Authority (November 3, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • National Bank of Canada v. Royal Bank of Canada (November 9, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Neinstein & Associates v. Bank of Nova Scotia Trust Company (November 7, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Ontario Human Rights Commission v. A. (November 14, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Perry, Farley & Onsychuk v. Outerbridge Management Limited (November 22, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Pieckenhagen v. 1030533 Ontario Limited (November 1, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Afghanzada (November 23, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Allen (November 6, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Bell (November 21, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Bero (November 3, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (November 6, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Coates (November 2, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Foisy (November 17, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. G., J. (November 28, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Guertin (November 20, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. H., H.A. (November 8, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. H., R.J. (November 21, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Hunter (November 3, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Igbinedion (November 3, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. L., B. (November 17, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Labuckas (November 9, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. McWatters (November 9, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Nee-Whang (November 3, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Niganobe (November 16, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Norman (November 3, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Pavich (November 9, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Seeley (November 17, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Shahnawaz (November 7, 2000) (Revised November 21, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Walker (November 3, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Watkins (November 2, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Z., A (November 1, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Seddon v. Carrier Canada Limited (November 2, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Simone v. Chiefetz (November 7, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Straka v. Humber River Regional Hospital (November 9, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Vibron Limited v. Kanatherm Limited (November 1, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Whitmell v. Tucker (November 1, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • World of Art Inc. v. Koninklijke Luchtvaart Maatschappij N.V. C.O.B. as KLM Royal Dutch Airlines (November 30, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Yackobeck v. Hartwig (November 28, 2000) HTMLPDF

December

  • 1224948 Ontario Ltd. v. 448332 Ontario Ltd. (December 22, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Apotex Inc. v. Hoffman La-Roche Limited (December 14, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Art Fleming & Sons Ent. Ltd. v. W.D. Laflamme limited (December 19, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Authorson v. Canada (Attorney General) (December 20, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Biggerstaff v. 934169 Ontario Limited (December 19, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Brummund v. Baumeister Estate (December 22, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Burgess v. Burgess Estate (December 22, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce v. Cicoria (December 8, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Canam Enterprises Inc. v. Coles (December 8, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Chippewas of Sarnia Band v. Canada (Attorney General) (December 21, 2000) HTMLPDF; Summary of Judgment HTMLPDF
  • Conte v. Alessandro (December 14, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Djukic v. Canada (Attorney General) (December 21, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Drumonde v. Moniz (December 20, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Glen Vending Limited v. Cornwall (City) (December 15, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Georgian Group Inc. v. Oakville Construction Ltd. (December 22, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Gryba v. Moneta Porcupine Mines Ltd. (December 20, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Iseman v. Ruthig (December 4, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Katsigannis v. Kottick-Katsigannis (December 7, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Macamid Holdings Ltd. v. 1013799 Ontario Limited (December 15, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Marketing Products Inc. v. 1254719 Ontario Ltd. (December 8, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Mastronardi (Re) (December 15, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Miller v. Cobra Industries Ltd. (December 8, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Mohammed v. Children’s Aid Society of Metropolitan Toronto (December 14, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • National Trust Company v. Hodgson (December 14, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Nilson v. Zagrodney (December 22, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Odhavji Estate v. Woodhouse (December 15, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Ontario (Attorney General) v. Ontario Public Service Employees Union (December 7, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Owen v. Zosky (December 22, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Piersanti & Company v. Ontario (December 4, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Pollard Windows Inc. v. Casale (December 15, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Ahluwalia (December 1, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Andrews (December 20, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Bianco (December 5, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Budd (December 11, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Chau (December 22, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Claus (December 4, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Codina (December 20, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Dharamdeo (December 4, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Fink (December 4, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Genereux (December 11, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Glaremin (December 21, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. H., T. (December 8, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Langevin (December 11, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Letford (December 22, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. M., G. (December 15, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. MacPherson (December 19, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Marriott (December 12, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Moir (December 1, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Ngo (December 27, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Nicely (December 20, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Paris (December 11, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Piersanti & Company (December 22, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Ploumis (December 13, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Sutherland (December 14, 2000) (Revised January 2, 2001) HTMLPDF
  • R. v. Venn (December 11, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Russell v. Shanahan (December 19, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • RTO Asset Managements Inc. v. Brewers Retail Inc. (December 8, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • S., H. v. H., R. (December 22, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Sellors v. Total Credit Recovery Limited (December 13, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Top v. West Wawanosh Mutual Insurance Company (December 15, 2000) HTMLPDF
  • Wheeler v. Wheeler (December 19, 2000 HTMLPDF
  • Wilson v. CGU Insurance Company of Canada (December 14, 2000) HTMLPDF
This website is maintained by the Judges' Library. Website Policies
to top